hi
I would like to give the following points in an Performance appraisal system.
(1) Target Vs. Achievements [this includes the quantitative/physical/financial targets/objective set for the employees and achievements thereon]
(2) State the reasons for not meeting the targets or constrain in achieving the target/short fall in the system, and specify it clearly
(3) State the areas where the employee made significant achievements.
(4) Assessment of knowledge/skill and application etc. (this varies from one type of job to another, for example, for an engineering job following are to assessed (not by the employee but by the appraiser):
(A)Intellectual ability -> Creativity, initiative, receptivity, drive, Intelligence
(B) Professional ability -> Theoretical ability, Experimental/Practical ability, Originality, Technical Judgement, power of Expression, General Professional Knowledge, Work Disposal etc.
(C) Managerial Ability -> Judgement, Organising ability, Leadership
(D) Admninistrative Competence -> Administrative Judgement, Understanding states, policies, rules etc; Knowledge of responsibility, Decision making ability,
besides this Personal qualities such as (a) Personality, (BA) integrity (c) conscientiousness, (d) sense of responsibility, (e) self reliances (f) amenability, cohesion, attitude towards superiors as well as colleagues, (g) discipline (h) loyalty etc.
When we get answers to the above points, it will be easy for us to asess an employee. this can be done on a periodical basis. Be it on a quarterly basis or Half yearly or yearly basis.
Assessor can grade the employee based on the above on a ten (10) point scale. The rating can be read as given below
10 means EXCEPTIONALLY BRILLIANT
09 means OUTSTANDING
08 means VERY GOOD
07 means GOOD
06 means Well ABOVE average Standard Person
05 means Good Average Person
04 Average Person
03 insufficient Initiative and capacity for work without constant supervision
02 Indifferent, but just worth retaining
01 Not worth retaining
After assessment, we can put a bench mark to improve the ratings, say at least the persons below the rate '5' should be given a opportunity to improve their performance to that level with in a stipulated period. So that the over all efficiency will improve.
I hope this will be helpful to you.
Bye
Ajay