Strike Under Industrial Disputes Act, 1947

swastik73
Can a strike called by workers of a public utility service ever be legal under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947? If yes, when? Please give me feedback.

Regards, SC
samvedan
Hi,

I wonder why some posts simply get no replies! I wish I had seen your post earlier.

Under the Industrial Disputes Act of 1947, a Public Utility service can go on a legal strike by giving the stipulated 14 days' notice. So, this right is granted by law. The idea behind the notice is to give the labor department sufficient time to conciliate between the parties in an attempt to resolve the dispute and extinguish the cause for the strike.

However, this rarely happens. Because it is a Public Utility Service and no populist government can afford the ire of its constituency, it rushes in with fiats like declaring the said service to be "essential service" and under the ESMA (Essential Services Maintenance Act), prohibiting the impending strike or banning the strike under the provisions of the ID Act itself while simultaneously referring the dispute to judicial determination.

The public at large may be pleased with such measures, but those poor guys serving in the said Public Utility Service find themselves in an unenviable situation of possessing a right that they are rarely permitted to use!

The answer to your query is, therefore, that the Public Utility Service has a right to go on a Legal strike only on paper. In reality, due to such encroachments described above, they rarely are on a legal strike!!!

Long Live Equality before Law!!!

Regards,

Samvedan

December 20, 2005
reena_aftab
Hi Reena,

Sure, I can provide you with information on strikes, layoffs, and lockouts.

During these situations, compensating workers is essential. There are various ways to compensate them, such as providing severance pay, offering benefits continuation, or implementing temporary pay arrangements.

Feel free to reach out if you have any further questions.

Thanks & Regards,
Samdev
samvedan
Hi,

In the last post, I only talked about the strikes in a Public Utility Industry. In this post, I will try to be comprehensive about the subject! I will confine to Maharashtra as that is where I work. Different States may have different provisions (though these can't be materially different from each other).

Everyone has a right to strike! Public Utility Industry's right is ferreted as explained in the last post. But all other industries can strike even without notice. (Maharashtra Recognition of Trade Unions and Unfair Labour Practices Act has some overlapping provisions also.)

The terms strike, lock-out, lay-off, retrenchment, and closure are all defined in the Industrial Disputes Act of 1947.

A strike or a lock-out may be legal or illegal. What is important is that not only at imposition but throughout its continuance it must also be justifiable. These actions must be legal and justifiable. When no notice is required to be given, a strike commenced suddenly may be legal at imposition but not necessarily justifiable.

The law does not compel parties per se to necessarily pay for the duration of the action. The party that imposes an action does so on the conviction that its action is legal and justified. Therefore, the aggrieved party has to "claim" wages by calling the strike/lock-out to be illegal and then proving it to be so!

A strike or a lock-out is the last weapon in the hands of the respective parties. When all else fails (collective bargaining, conciliation, etc.), a party may resort to such an action in an effort to force the other party to see things its way and concede its demands.

If the dispute over which the action was initiated, the party may, while settling the main dispute, settle this matter also - one way or the other. Even if matters involving wages for the strike or the lock-out period go to court for judicial determination, the parties are free to continue a dialogue and settle the matter "out of court," but then they will have to obtain an "award in terms of the settlement." This is not very difficult once the court finds the settlement fair and amicable!

Now, look, I think I have said a lot and even scratched the surface. Every question connected with this subject is intertwined with some aspect of law and case law, and therefore the bare act is to be followed carefully.

I would be in a position to help you better if you raise specific questions. For the time being, your question/s have been answered!

Tell me you are satisfied or raise questions till you are!!

Regards,

Samvedan

August 14, 2006
samvedan
Hi,

First, one must study the actual provisions outlined in the Industrial Disputes Act 1947, accompanied by the Rules made by the State Government of the state in which you operate and possibly related acts like, particularly, the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act 1946. In Maharashtra, one must also study the Maharashtra Recognition of Trade Unions and Prevention of Unfair Labour Practices Act.

Thereafter, one should make it a habit to follow court decisions made by various courts on the subject. There are journals like the Current Labour Reports (published from Mumbai), Labour & Industrial Cases (published from Nagpur), and the like. These are quite prominent. They publish judgments of all labor cases covering all labor disputes coming up before them, decided by various High Courts and the Supreme Court.

This is a great resource. Any practicing Labor advocate in your city will also guide you and at least provide you with the address of these publishers if you wish to subscribe! But study a few issues from the advocate's library and then decide!

Regards,

Samvedan

August 15, 2006
swastik73
Dear Vinay,

Please look up the chapters on Strikes and Lockouts under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.

Regards,
SC
reena_aftab
Hi Samdev,

Thanks for your reply, but I am still in confusion. Can you please tell me about the compensation regarding this period and about retrenchment? What is this?

Regards,
Reena
swastik73
Dear Reena,

The whole issue of compensation during lockout and closure is explained in detail in the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, as is the term "Retrenchment" and the compensation relating to retrenchment. Please go through it.

Click the link and look up the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947: [http://www.vakilno1.com](http://www.vakilno1.com)

Regards,
SC
sivamaheshv
Please provide me with complete information about collective bargaining. I need it urgently. If anyone has PowerPoint presentations (PPTs) on this topic, it would be really helpful to me. Please assist me.

Thanks & regards,
V. Sivamahesh
vardhani27
Thank you so much for the Industrial Dispute Act presentation. I need some important notes on company acts in a PowerPoint format.

Thank you so much for sharing the Industrial Dispute Act presentation.

Thank you so much for the Industrial Dispute Act presentation.
If you are knowledgeable about any fact, resource or experience related to this topic - please add your views. For articles and copyrighted material please only cite the original source link. Each contribution will make this page a resource useful for everyone. Join To Contribute